Behavior-Elastic Demand Curves: Neuro-Marketing Integration and Its Impact on Optimal Pricing Strategies¶

1. Introduction¶

The integration of behavior-elastic demand curves derived from neuro-marketing data represents a significant advancement in the field of marketing science. Traditional price-elastic demand curves, while useful for predicting consumer buying behavior based on price changes, have several limitations that behavior-elastic curves aim to address. Specifically, traditional models often fail to capture the multifaceted nature of consumer decision-making, which includes cognitive and emotional factors beyond mere price sensitivity. This oversight can lead to suboptimal pricing strategies and a lack of alignment with consumer preferences and market conditions.

The literature review section of this report explores the foundational concepts and methodologies of price elasticity, the emerging field of behavior elasticity, and the advanced neuro-marketing techniques that underpin the latter. We begin by examining the traditional economic models of price elasticity, including the mid-point method, log-log regression, and ensemble models, and discussing their limitations and empirical evidence. Next, we delve into the concept of behavior elasticity, which integrates psychological and behavioral factors derived from neuro-marketing data to provide a more nuanced understanding of consumer behavior. Finally, we review the key neuro-marketing techniques such as fMRI, EEG, eye tracking, and facial coding, and their practical applications in marketing, along with the ethical considerations associated with these methods.

This structured approach sets the stage for a comprehensive analysis of the integration of behavior-elastic curves into optimal pricing strategies. The subsequent sections will explore the methodologies for constructing behavior-elastic curves, the impact of these curves on pricing strategies, and the challenges and limitations associated with their implementation. By addressing these topics, this report aims to provide researchers and experts with a thorough understanding of the potential and practical implications of behavior-elastic demand curves in the modern marketing landscape.

Having provided an overview of the research topic and its significance, the following section will delve into the background of consumer behavior and the limitations of traditional price-elastic demand curves.

1.1. Background¶

Price elasticity of demand is a fundamental economic concept that quantifies the responsiveness of the quantity demanded of a product to changes in its price. It is expressed as a ratio, where:

[ \text{Price Elasticity of Demand} = \frac{\text{Percentage Change in Quantity Demanded}}{\text{Percentage Change in Price}} ]

The elasticity can range from zero to infinity, indicating different levels of consumer responsiveness. Key points include:

• Elastic Demand: If the elasticity is greater than 1, the demand is considered elastic. This means that a small change in price leads to a significant change in the quantity demanded. Products with many substitutes or those that are not essential tend to have elastic demand. For example, if the price of coffee increases, consumers might switch to tea, leading to a substantial drop in coffee demand [10].

• Inelastic Demand: If the elasticity is less than 1, the demand is considered inelastic. This indicates that a change in price has a minimal effect on the quantity demanded. Products that are necessities or have few substitutes exhibit inelastic demand. For instance, gasoline demand remains relatively stable even with price increases because there are few alternatives and it is essential for transportation [10].

• Unitary Elasticity: If the elasticity is exactly 1, the demand is unitary elastic. Here, a percentage change in price results in an equal percentage change in quantity demanded.

• Perfectly Inelastic Demand: If the elasticity is 0, the demand is perfectly inelastic. No amount of price change affects the quantity demanded. Examples include life-saving medications or essential utilities [10].

• Perfectly Elastic Demand: If the elasticity is infinite, the demand is perfectly elastic. Any small price increase will cause the quantity demanded to drop to zero, and any small price decrease will cause the quantity demanded to rise infinitely. This is rare in real-world scenarios [10].

Several factors influence the price elasticity of demand:

• Availability of Substitutes: The more substitutes available, the more elastic the demand. For example, if both coffee and tea are popular, a price increase in coffee will lead consumers to switch to tea [10].

• Urgency: Discretionary purchases are more elastic than non-discretionary ones. For instance, a new washing machine is a discretionary purchase, and consumers might delay buying if the price increases [10].

• Duration of Price Change: Short-term price changes (e.g., sales) elicit different responses compared to long-term price changes. Consumers might accept higher prices for seasonal products like swimsuits during summer [10].

Traditional methods for calculating price elasticity of demand include:

• Mid-Point Method: This method is a simple formula based on the price coefficient of a multi-linear regression model and the ratio of average prices and units in the modeling period, typically two years of weekly data. It is useful for directional estimates and clustering products or customers based on pricing behavior [12].

• Log-Log Regression: This method involves regressing the log of units sold on the log of price and other variables. The price coefficient from this regression is roughly the price elasticity. Log-log regressions are effective for products where there is often a linear relationship between prices and volume, particularly for the top 25-50% of assortment products [12].

• Ensemble Models: These models, such as random forest or gradient boosting, are more robust and can handle multi-collinearity and provide higher predictive accuracy. They are particularly useful for well-established products with extensive sales history and competitive pricing trends [12].

Another econometric model used is the nested multinomial logit with random coefficients, which allows for the depiction of a consumer's decision to buy in a given product category and, conditional on choosing to buy in a category, which product to buy within the category. This model combines decisions to substitute across product categories and within product categories [18].

Understanding the elasticity of demand for a product helps businesses make informed decisions about pricing strategies. For products with inelastic demand, businesses can increase prices without significantly affecting the quantity demanded, whereas for products with elastic demand, price increases can lead to substantial decreases in demand [10]. Businesses in industries with high multi-collinearity and complex pricing dynamics should consider using ensemble models to achieve more accurate price elasticities. For simpler industries, traditional log-log regressions can still be effective [12]. Survey-based methods and in-market price tests are also valuable for new products or brand repositioning, providing reliable results for decision-making [12].

Having reviewed the fundamental concepts and methodologies of price elasticity, the following section will explore the emerging concept of behavior-elastic demand curves, which incorporate psychological and behavioral factors derived from neuro-marketing data to offer a more nuanced understanding of consumer behavior.

1.2. Research Objectives¶

The primary objectives of this research are to explore the integration of behavior-elastic curves derived from neuro-marketing data into traditional economic models and to assess their impact on optimal pricing strategies. Specifically, this study aims to:

1. Define and Theorize Behavior-Elastic Curves: Develop a comprehensive theoretical framework for behavior-elastic demand curves, which incorporate psychological and behavioral factors beyond price sensitivity. This will involve a detailed examination of the cognitive and emotional processes that influence consumer decision-making and how these processes can be captured and quantified using neuro-marketing techniques [8].

2. Methodologies for Data Collection: Investigate the methodologies and processes for collecting neuro-marketing data to construct behavior-elastic curves. This will include the use of Electroencephalography (EEG), eye tracking, and facial coding, as well as the integration of these techniques to provide a more nuanced and reliable understanding of consumer behavior [5].

3. Curve Derivation Techniques: Analyze the techniques used to derive behavior-elastic curves from the collected neuro-marketing data. This will involve a detailed exploration of data pre-processing, feature extraction, classification, and statistical analysis methods, with a focus on the application of machine learning algorithms to enhance the precision of curve derivation [17].

4. Theoretical Impact on Pricing Strategies: Evaluate the theoretical implications of using behavior-elastic curves for pricing decisions. This will include an examination of how these curves can address the limitations of traditional price-elastic demand curves by incorporating a broader range of consumer behavior factors, such as satisfaction, income levels, and psychological influences [25].

5. Empirical Analysis of Pricing Strategies: Conduct empirical studies to demonstrate the effectiveness of behavior-elastic curves in optimizing pricing strategies. This will involve analyzing real-world applications and comparing the outcomes with those achieved using traditional price-elastic models to highlight the practical benefits and challenges of adopting behavior-elastic curves [5].

6. Challenges and Limitations: Identify and discuss the ethical, financial, methodological, and regulatory challenges associated with the implementation of behavior-elastic demand curves. This will include an exploration of data privacy concerns, the high cost of neuroimaging technology, technical feasibility issues, and the need for a robust regulatory framework to ensure responsible and sustainable adoption [2].

By addressing these objectives, this research aims to provide a thorough understanding of the potential and practical implications of behavior-elastic demand curves in the modern marketing landscape. The following section will delve into the methodologies for constructing these curves.

2. Literature Review¶

The literature review section explores the foundational concepts and methodologies of price elasticity, the emerging field of behavior elasticity, and the advanced neuro-marketing techniques that underpin the latter. We begin by examining the traditional economic models of price elasticity, including the mid-point method, log-log regression, and ensemble models, and discussing their limitations and empirical evidence. Next, we delve into the concept of behavior elasticity, which integrates psychological and behavioral factors derived from neuro-marketing data to provide a more nuanced understanding of consumer behavior. Finally, we review the key neuro-marketing techniques such as fMRI, EEG, eye tracking, and facial coding, and their practical applications in marketing, along with the ethical considerations associated with these methods. This structured approach sets the stage for a comprehensive analysis of the integration of behavior-elastic curves into optimal pricing strategies.

2.1. Price Elasticity¶

Price elasticity of demand is a fundamental economic concept that quantifies the responsiveness of the quantity demanded of a product to changes in its price. It is expressed as a ratio, where:

[ \text{Price Elasticity of Demand} = \frac{\text{Percentage Change in Quantity Demanded}}{\text{Percentage Change in Price}} ]

The elasticity can range from zero to infinity, indicating different levels of consumer responsiveness. Key points include:

1. Elastic Demand: If the elasticity is greater than 1, the demand is considered elastic. This means that a small change in price leads to a significant change in the quantity demanded. Products with many substitutes or those that are not essential tend to have elastic demand. For example, if the price of coffee increases, consumers might switch to tea, leading to a substantial drop in coffee demand [10].

2. Inelastic Demand: If the elasticity is less than 1, the demand is considered inelastic. This indicates that a change in price has a minimal effect on the quantity demanded. Products that are necessities or have few substitutes exhibit inelastic demand. For instance, gasoline demand remains relatively stable even with price increases because there are few alternatives and it is essential for transportation [10].

3. Unitary Elasticity: If the elasticity is exactly 1, the demand is unitary elastic. Here, a percentage change in price results in an equal percentage change in quantity demanded.

4. Perfectly Inelastic Demand: If the elasticity is 0, the demand is perfectly inelastic. No amount of price change affects the quantity demanded. Examples include life-saving medications or essential utilities [10].

5. Perfectly Elastic Demand: If the elasticity is infinite, the demand is perfectly elastic. Any small price increase will cause the quantity demanded to drop to zero, and any small price decrease will cause the quantity demanded to rise infinitely. This is rare in real-world scenarios [10].

Factors Affecting Price Elasticity of Demand:

Several factors influence the price elasticity of demand:

• Availability of Substitutes: The more substitutes available, the more elastic the demand. For example, if both coffee and tea are popular, a price increase in coffee will lead consumers to switch to tea [10].
• Urgency: Discretionary purchases are more elastic than non-discretionary ones. For instance, a new washing machine is a discretionary purchase, and consumers might delay buying if the price increases [10].
• Duration of Price Change: Short-term price changes (e.g., sales) elicit different responses compared to long-term price changes. Consumers might accept higher prices for seasonal products like swimsuits during summer [10].

Mathematical Models for Price Elasticity of Demand:

Traditional methods for calculating price elasticity of demand include:

• Mid-Point Method: This method is a simple formula based on the price coefficient of a multi-linear regression model and the ratio of average prices and units in the modeling period, typically two years of weekly data. It is useful for directional estimates and clustering products or customers based on pricing behavior [12].
• Log-Log Regression: This method involves regressing the log of units sold on the log of price and other variables. The price coefficient from this regression is roughly the price elasticity. Log-log regressions are effective for products where there is often a linear relationship between prices and volume, particularly for the top 25-50% of assortment products [12].
• Ensemble Models: These models, such as random forest or gradient boosting, are more robust and can handle multi-collinearity and provide higher predictive accuracy. They are particularly useful for well-established products with extensive sales history and competitive pricing trends [12].

Another econometric model used is the nested multinomial logit with random coefficients, which allows for the depiction of a consumer's decision to buy in a given product category and, conditional on choosing to buy in a category, which product to buy within the category. This model combines decisions to substitute across product categories and within product categories [18].

Application and Accuracy:

OLS coefficients provide an estimate of the impact of a unit change in the independent variable (X) on the dependent variable (Y) measured in units of Y. However, these coefficients are not elasticities. Elasticities are measured in percentage terms, allowing for direct comparison across different goods and markets. Along a straight-line demand curve, the percentage change in quantity demanded (elasticity) varies continuously with the scale of the price change, while the slope (regression coefficient) remains constant. Estimating elasticity at the point of means (average values of price and quantity) is a conventional approach to provide a meaningful and representative elasticity measure [22].

Empirical Evidence and Limitations:

Empirical evidence shows that the price elasticity of demand for goods with few substitutes, such as gasoline, is inelastic (less than 1). For example, a 16% increase in the price of gasoline resulted in only a 4% decrease in demand, indicating an elasticity of 0.25 [22]. Goods with many substitutes, such as fruits (apples, pears, plums, grapes), have elastic demand (greater than 1), meaning a small percentage change in price can lead to a large percentage change in quantity demanded [22].

The limitations of traditional price-elastic demand curves include:

• High Multi-Collinearity: Traditional regression models can suffer from high multi-collinearity of predictors (e.g., price and promotional periods, display advertising), leading to less accurate price elasticity estimates. Advanced models like ensemble models are recommended to address these issues [12].
• Variability in Elasticity: The elasticity of demand is not constant across all price ranges; it varies along the demand curve. This variability poses a challenge for accurate measurement, especially when the price change is significant. To address this, methods such as arc elasticity and point elasticity have been developed. Arc elasticity calculates the average elasticity over a segment of the demand curve, providing a more reliable measure for larger price changes. Point elasticity, on the other hand, measures the elasticity at a specific point on the demand curve using differential calculus, which is more precise for infinitesimal changes but requires the exact demand function [9].

Notable Criticisms and Alternative Views:

The values for super-elasticities in the macro literature are often criticized for being unrealistic. Empirical evidence from a study using homescan data shows that the estimated super-elasticities are positive but small, with a median of 1.6. This suggests that traditional models with large super-elasticities are extreme cases and do not align with micro-based evidence [18]. More moderate values, such as those assumed in Bergin and Feenstra (2000) and Gopinath and Itskhoki (2010), are closer to the majority of empirical estimates [18].

Impact of Consumer Income and Availability of Substitutes:

Changes in consumer income and the availability of substitutes significantly affect the price elasticity of demand. For instance, poorer households tend to have higher demand elasticities compared to richer households, indicating that changes in consumer income can significantly affect the price elasticity of demand [18]. The availability of substitutes is also a factor, as the model captures the idea that consumers with higher demand elasticities tend to purchase closer to the consumption date, suggesting that the presence of close substitutes can increase price sensitivity [18].

Implications for Businesses:

Understanding the elasticity of demand for a product helps businesses make informed decisions about pricing strategies. For products with inelastic demand, businesses can increase prices without significantly affecting the quantity demanded, whereas for products with elastic demand, price increases can lead to substantial decreases in demand [10]. Businesses in industries with high multi-collinearity and complex pricing dynamics should consider using ensemble models to achieve more accurate price elasticities. For simpler industries, traditional log-log regressions can still be effective [12]. Survey-based methods and in-market price tests are also valuable for new products or brand repositioning, providing reliable results for decision-making [12].

Having reviewed the fundamental concepts and methodologies of price elasticity, the following section will explore the emerging concept of behavior-elastic demand curves, which incorporate psychological and behavioral factors derived from neuro-marketing data to offer a more nuanced understanding of consumer behavior.

2.2. Behavior Elasticity¶

Behavior elasticity represents a significant advancement in marketing science by integrating psychological and behavioral factors derived from neuro-marketing data into traditional economic models. Unlike price elasticity, which focuses solely on the quantitative response to price changes, behavior elasticity considers the broader spectrum of consumer behavior, including cognitive and emotional responses, to provide a more comprehensive understanding of consumer preferences and decision-making processes.

Electroencephalography (EEG) is a powerful neuroscientific technology that plays a crucial role in deriving behavior-elastic curves. EEG measures brain activity by recording electrical signals on the scalp, offering real-time insights into consumer cognitive and emotional states. This technology has been widely used in consumer neuroscience and neuromarketing to analyze perceptual constructs and improve the internal validity of studies on consumer psychology [3]. For instance, EEG has been employed to predict consumer preferences and emotional responses to various stimuli, such as product images, video ads, and packaging designs [4]. Studies by Yadava et al. [8] and Teo et al. [39] have developed predictive models using machine learning to identify consumer intentions and preferences, demonstrating the potential of EEG in enhancing marketing strategies [4].

The integration of EEG with other biometric measures, such as eye tracking and skin conductance, allows for a more comprehensive analysis of consumer behavior. Hybrid schemes combining EEG with eye tracking have been used to study visual attention to social media and its impact on restaurant visit intentions [3]. Similarly, the combination of EEG with skin conductance has been applied to understand consumer reactions to food packaging [3]. These multimodal approaches provide a more nuanced and reliable understanding of consumer responses, which is essential for the derivation of behavior-elastic curves.

Machine learning algorithms, particularly those designed for high-dimensional data, are effective in predicting consumers' future choices from EEG signals. These algorithms can process complex neural patterns and extract meaningful features that correlate with consumer behavior, enhancing the precision of behavior-elastic curve derivation [15]. For example, mutual information analysis has been used to quantify the importance of different product features, such as flavors and toppings, in influencing consumer preferences [5]. This method, combined with discrete choice experiments (DCE), offers a more natural and less biased way to measure consumer preferences, which can be integrated into traditional economic models to refine pricing strategies [5].

The use of event-related potentials (ERP) and time-frequency (TF) analysis in EEG data further enriches the understanding of consumer behavior. ERP measures, such as the N400 and P300 components, reflect cognitive and emotional processes during decision-making. The N400 component is particularly useful for detecting conflict and unfamiliarity, while the P300 component is effective in investigating advertising and marketing effectiveness [17]. TF analysis, especially the alpha band, modulates visual processing, attentional orienting, decision-making, and emotional regulation, making it a valuable tool for assessing consumer responses to advertisements and products [17].

Despite the advantages of neuro-marketing techniques, ethical considerations and limitations remain significant challenges. The responsible use of EEG data and the interpretation of brain activity must be conducted with transparency and adherence to ethical guidelines to protect consumer privacy and ensure the validity of the findings [15]. The complexity of interpreting brain signals and the challenges in translating these signals into meaningful consumer preferences are acknowledged in the literature [5]. Additionally, the spatial accuracy of EEG and the reverse inference problem, where brain activity is used to infer cognitive processes, pose ongoing challenges [7].

In summary, behavior elasticity, derived from neuro-marketing data, offers a more nuanced and accurate representation of consumer behavior compared to traditional price elasticity. The integration of EEG with other biometric measures and the application of machine learning algorithms provide valuable insights into consumer preferences and decision-making processes. However, the ethical and methodological challenges associated with these techniques must be carefully addressed to ensure their sustainable and responsible adoption. The following section will delve into the specific neuro-marketing techniques used in the derivation of behavior-elastic curves.

2.3. Neuro-Marketing Techniques¶

Neuro-marketing techniques provide a deeper and more nuanced understanding of consumer behavior and preferences compared to traditional survey methods. These techniques leverage neuroscientific methods to capture unconscious neural and physiological responses, which can be used to inform and optimize marketing strategies. The key techniques include functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI), electroencephalography (EEG), eye tracking, and facial coding.

fMRI (Functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging): fMRI measures brain activity by detecting changes in blood flow, providing insights into the neural correlates of consumer behavior. This technique is particularly useful for identifying specific brain regions involved in decision-making, such as the prefrontal cortex and the amygdala. For example, fMRI has been used to forecast chocolate sales at point-of-sale by identifying functional brain activation patterns associated with purchasing behavior [13]. Another study demonstrated that fMRI can reveal distinct functional pathways engaged in the perception of organic versus popular brands [13]. The integration of fMRI with other neuroscientific tools like EEG and eye tracking enhances the multifaceted insights gained from these methods [1].

EEG (Electroencephalography): EEG measures electrical activity in the brain, offering real-time insights into consumer cognitive and emotional states. It is particularly useful for assessing the effectiveness of advertising messages and consumer responses to marketing stimuli. An EEG study found that emotional intelligence can influence the effectiveness of advertising messages [13]. EEG has also been used to predict consumers' future choices, providing valuable data for marketing strategies [4]. For instance, the integration of EEG with machine learning algorithms can forecast behavior from brain imaging data using both spectral analysis and ERPs as classifiers [7]. This approach has shown promise in predicting consumer preferences and willingness to pay, thereby aiding in the creation of behavior-elastic curves.

Eye Tracking (ET): Eye tracking measures where and how long consumers look at specific elements in marketing materials, providing insights into visual attention and processing. This technique is effective in understanding how consumers process information and their attentional biases. For example, eye tracking can show whether a customer notices a call-to-action button or overlooks key branding elements [6]. Eye tracking has been applied to assess the effectiveness of health warning cues in anti-smoking PSAs, revealing which elements are most visually appealing to consumers [6]. Additionally, eye tracking measures fixation points, gaze duration, eye movement with the head, blink rate, and pupil dilation, which can indicate attention and emotional states [24]. The combination of eye tracking with other biometric measures, such as facial coding and galvanic skin response, offers a more comprehensive analysis of consumer behavior [24].

Facial Coding: Facial coding involves analyzing microexpressions to detect emotional reactions, allowing marketers to refine content based on subconscious consumer responses such as happiness, surprise, or frustration. While not as extensively covered in the literature as other techniques, facial coding is often used alongside EEG and eye tracking to enhance the accuracy of emotional response measurements. For instance, software packages integrate eye tracking and facial coding, allowing simultaneous capture and analysis of visual and emotional data [24]. Marketers can use this data to ensure that ads trigger the intended emotional responses and that attention is focused on key elements like logos [24].

Combination of Techniques: Combining multiple neuro-marketing techniques (fMRI, EEG, eye tracking) can provide a more comprehensive understanding of consumer behavior. For example, an integrative study used EEG, eye tracking, and galvanic skin response to assess the perception of antismoking public service announcements, offering deeper insights into consumer responses [13]. Another study combined EEG with measures of vigilance (alpha-activity), emotional valence (alpha-asymmetry), and cognitive resources (ERP) to analyze neurophysiological reactions toward tactile stimuli, such as different fabrics [7]. These hybrid schemes have been effective in providing a richer and more nuanced view of consumer behavior, which is essential for deriving behavior-elastic curves.

Practical Applications: These techniques have been applied across various product categories to enhance marketing strategies. For instance, Frito-Lay used fMRI and eye tracking to test chip packaging designs, leading to changes in packaging to avoid negative consumer responses [19]. The National Cancer Institute used fMRI to test anti-smoking commercials, resulting in increased hotline calls from the ad that received favorable reactions [19]. IKEA designed store layouts using neuromarketing research to increase the likelihood of purchases by showcasing all products before the exit [19]. FedEx included a hidden arrow in their logo to represent quickness, garnering favorable subconscious reactions from consumers [19]. Color research has found that the color red signifies strength, influencing the logo design of brands like Coca-Cola, Target, McDonald’s, and Netflix [19].

Ethical Considerations: The use of neuro-marketing techniques raises significant ethical concerns, particularly around consumer privacy and manipulation. Stealth marketing, which leverages subtle persuasive cues derived from neuroscience, can influence consumers subconsciously, leading to potential ethical violations [2]. The collection and analysis of biometric and brain data must be carefully managed to protect consumer rights and prevent unauthorized use of personal information. Companies should have robust ethical protocols and crisis communication plans to address potential public backlash [19].

Having examined the key neuro-marketing techniques and their applications, the following section will explore the methodologies for constructing behavior-elastic demand curves.

3. Neuro-Marketing Methods¶

Neuro-marketing methods, such as Electroencephalography (EEG), functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging (fMRI), eye tracking, and facial coding, offer advanced techniques for gathering data on consumer behavior. Each method has unique advantages and limitations, contributing to the derivation of behavior-elastic demand curves that can inform optimal pricing strategies. This section will begin by examining EEG, which captures real-time brain activity and is particularly useful for understanding cognitive and emotional states during decision-making. We will then explore fMRI, a non-invasive technique that provides deep insights into the neural correlates of consumer behavior, including impulsiveness, reward, and trust. Following this, we will discuss eye tracking, which measures visual attention and is valuable for optimizing retail layouts and advertising effectiveness. Finally, we will consider facial coding, a method that analyzes consumers' emotional responses through facial micro-expressions, enhancing the reliability of emotion recognition in marketing research.

3.1. EEG¶

Electroencephalography (EEG) is a neuroscientific technique that measures electrical activity in the brain, providing real-time insights into consumer cognitive and emotional states. This method is particularly valuable in neuromarketing for capturing brain responses to marketing stimuli, which can be used to derive behavior-elastic curves. The process of using EEG in neuromarketing involves several key stages: data collection, pre-processing, feature extraction, classification, and statistical analysis.

Data Collection: Researchers create realistic buying scenarios to understand consumers' thoughts and preferences when selecting products. EEG data is collected from specific brain regions known to be involved in emotional and decision-making processes related to purchase intention. For example, a study by Yadava et al. used a commercial Emotiv EPOC wireless EEG headset with 14 channels to collect brain signals from participants, paired with a Tobii-Studio eye tracker to correlate brain activity with specific choice options [5]. Participants were presented with 57 choice sets, each containing three different crackers described by shape, flavor, and topping, and were asked to select their most and least favorite crackers, providing a discrete indicator of preferences.

Pre-Processing: The collected EEG data is often very noisy and requires various pre-processing techniques to clean it up. These techniques aim to remove noise while preserving essential information. Common pre-processing methods include filtering, artifact removal, and normalization [20]. Effective pre-processing is crucial for ensuring the accuracy and reliability of subsequent analyses.

Feature Extraction: After pre-processing, features are extracted from the EEG data. Different techniques are used to extract time domain, frequency domain, and time–frequency domain features. For instance, time-frequency (TF) analysis, particularly the alpha band, modulates visual processing, attentional orienting, decision-making, and emotional regulation, making it a valuable tool for assessing consumer responses to advertisements and products [17]. Event-related potentials (ERPs), such as the N400 and P300 components, reflect cognitive and emotional processes during decision-making. The N400 component is particularly useful for detecting conflict and unfamiliarity, while the P300 component is effective in investigating advertising and marketing effectiveness [17].

Classification and Statistical Analysis: Extracted features are used for classification purposes and statistical analyses. Machine learning algorithms, particularly those designed for high-dimensional data, are effective in predicting consumer preferences from EEG signals. For example, deep neural networks (DNN) have achieved the highest binary classification accuracy (85–94%), followed by random forests (RF) (80%), support vector machines (SVM) (77%), and k-nearest neighbors (KNN) (72%) [17]. Regression methods, however, have the lowest accuracy (60%). These models can overcome reliability issues but require a larger number of trials and computational power, and are vulnerable to overfitting [17].

Interpretation: Proper selection of pre-processing and feature extraction techniques is crucial for accurate data interpretation. Hybrid schemes, such as combining EEG with eye-tracking, electrodermal activity, and heart rate, can provide more comprehensive insights but also introduce ethical considerations [20]. For instance, the combination of EEG with eye tracking has been used to study visual attention to social media and its impact on restaurant visit intentions [3]. Similarly, the integration of EEG with skin conductance has been applied to understand consumer reactions to food packaging [3].

Ethical Considerations and Limitations: The ethical considerations and limitations of using neuro-marketing data to create behavior-elastic curves are significant. The responsible use of EEG data and the interpretation of brain activity must be conducted with transparency and adherence to ethical guidelines to protect consumer privacy and ensure the validity of the findings [15]. The complexity of interpreting brain signals and the challenges in translating these signals into meaningful consumer preferences are acknowledged in the literature [5]. Additionally, the spatial accuracy of EEG and the reverse inference problem, where brain activity is used to infer cognitive processes, pose ongoing challenges [7].

Having examined the use of EEG in capturing brain activity and its application in deriving behavior-elastic curves, the following section will delve into the use of functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) in neuro-marketing.

3.2. fMRI¶

Functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging (fMRI) is a neuroimaging technique that measures brain activity by detecting changes in blood flow, which is indicative of neural activity. This method has been extensively utilized in neuromarketing research to gain insights into the neural correlates of consumer behavior, particularly in areas such as impulsiveness, reward, emotion, and decision-making. fMRI provides a non-invasive way to observe brain activity in response to various marketing stimuli, including price, advertising, product design, and brand perception.

One of the key strengths of fMRI is its ability to capture both conscious and unconscious emotional and cognitive reactions deep within the brain. For example, fMRI has been used to forecast chocolate sales at point-of-sale by identifying functional brain activation patterns associated with purchasing behavior [13]. Another study demonstrated that fMRI can reveal distinct functional pathways engaged in the perception of organic versus popular brands, highlighting the neural differences in how consumers process these brand types [13]. These findings underscore the utility of fMRI in understanding the underlying mechanisms of consumer decision-making and preferences.

fMRI has also been employed to study the impact of brand recognition on consumer behavior. An fMRI study showed enhanced activity in the emotional and memory regions of the brain when subjects recognized the Coca-Cola brand compared to when the brand was not identified, indicating the significant influence of branding beyond price [26]. Similarly, a study using fMRI to examine the perception of wine found that brain activity varied based on the labeled price of the wine, even when the actual quality remained constant, suggesting that perceived value can independently influence consumer behavior [26].

The integration of fMRI with other neuroscientific tools, such as EEG and eye tracking, has been emphasized for gaining multifaceted insights into consumer behavior. A comprehensive literature review of 36 Scopus-indexed articles from 2007 to 2021 highlighted the USA's dominance in fMRI neuromarketing research, with key contributions from institutions like the California Institute of Technology, Otto-Von-Guericke University, and Aarhus University [1]. The most cited articles, such as "Marketing actions can modulate neural representations of experienced pleasantness" by Plassmann et al. (620 citations) and "Orbitofrontal cortex encodes willingness to pay in everyday economic transactions" by Plassmann et al. (563 citations), demonstrate the utility of fMRI in understanding neural correlates of consumer behavior, including decision-making, attention, emotion, and reward [1].

The proposed flowchart for using fMRI in marketing research outlines steps from setting clear research objectives to applying insights to refine marketing strategies, emphasizing the importance of ethical considerations, participant diversity, and precise experimental design. This approach allows for the capture of unconscious emotional and cognitive reactions to marketing stimuli, providing deeper and more nuanced insights compared to traditional survey methods [1].

fMRI has been applied in various contexts to predict consumer behavior and sales. For instance, a study by Neurensics, a company specializing in neuro-marketing, found that fMRI signals during communications were the best predictors of actual sales, outperforming both pre- and post-messaging fMRI data and stated preferences [26]. This suggests that small-scale neuromarketing tests using fMRI can accurately forecast consumer behavior, making it a valuable tool for businesses seeking to optimize their marketing strategies.

In addition to forecasting sales, fMRI has been used to predict crowdfunding outcomes. A study recorded brain activity of 30 subjects while they decided whether to fund 36 crowdfunding projects on Kickstarter. The results indicated that brain activity, particularly in the Nucleus accumbens (NAcc), was a better predictor of market-level crowdfunding outcomes than subjects' ratings of project likeability or perceived likelihood of success [26]. This highlights the potential of fMRI to provide more reliable forecasts of mass consumer behavior, which can inform strategic decisions in fundraising and product development.

fMRI also plays a crucial role in understanding the neurophysiological basis of consumer trust. A study tested 245 students' trust in a website under low-risk and high-risk scenarios, finding that high-risk decisions rely more on intuitive reasoning processes, influenced by the website's aesthetic design rather than explicit trust guarantees [26]. This suggests that seemingly minor design elements can significantly impact consumer trust in high-risk situations, providing valuable insights for web design and online marketing.

Finally, fMRI has been used to study the neural responses to different payment methods. MRI scans of 30 participants during online purchases using different payment methods (debit cards and PayPal) revealed that PayPal, a trusted payment method, activates brain areas linked to reward prediction, while debit card payments activate areas associated with negative emotional processing [26]. This indicates that offering familiar, trusted payment options can reduce buying friction and enhance consumer confidence, which is critical for e-commerce and online transactions.

Having examined the role of fMRI in studying consumer behavior, the following section will explore the use of eye tracking in neuro-marketing.

3.3. Eye Tracking¶

Eye tracking is a neuro-marketing technique that involves studying people's eye movements to analyze their behavior, both in laboratory settings and real-life scenarios (Campos, 2017). The devices used for eye tracking are small and unobtrusive, allowing participants to wear them while shopping, watching television, or interacting with digital content. This method provides detailed data on various aspects of consumer attention, including fixation points, gaze duration, eye movement with the head, blink rate, and pupil dilation (Zurawicki, 2010). For example, fixation durations can vary from 200 milliseconds for reading text to 350 milliseconds for viewing scenes, and scan path analysis, involving a series of fixations and saccades, helps in understanding visual attention, cognitive intent, and relevance (Zurawicki, 2010).

In the context of retail, eye tracking can reveal the level of attention consumers pay to items near the store’s entrance, whether they read billboards and posters or merely glance at them, and how attention is distributed when choosing products from shelves (Campos, 2017). This data is invaluable for optimizing store layouts and product placements to maximize consumer engagement and sales. For instance, a study by dos Santos et al. (2015) found that eye tracking can enhance online sales by identifying checkout challenges and improving the user experience.

In advertising, companies use eye tracking to measure and influence viewer attention. One notable application is the use of close-ups of babies in advertisements. When the baby looks at the product, viewers are more likely to focus on the content, effectively increasing the ad's impact (Farnsworth, 2019). Eye tracking can also be combined with other biometric measures, such as facial coding and skin conductance, to gain further insights into cognitive responses (Harrell, 2019). This combination provides synchronized data on visual activity and emotional responses, offering deeper insights into consumer behavior (Hill, 2011). For example, TV advertisements generate a large amount of data quickly, which can help identify positive and negative attention drivers (Ho, 2014).

Eye movements during decision-making are influenced by both top-down and bottom-up factors. Bottom-up factors are features of the stimuli that rapidly capture attention, such as bright colors or moving objects (Pieters & Wedel, 2004). Top-down factors, on the other hand, are pre-existing ideas or intentions that guide attention to specific product information, such as brand loyalty or past experiences (Behe et al., 2013). Understanding these factors can help marketers design more effective campaigns that align with consumer cognitive processes.

Despite the sophistication of eye tracking, cost and accessibility remain important considerations. Less costly tools like eye tracking and facial coding are more widely adopted by neuromarketers due to their practicality and ease of use (Harrell, 2019). Leading consultancies, such as Nielsen, emphasize the importance of using multiple tools in combination to achieve comprehensive insights (Harrell, 2019).

Having examined the use of eye tracking in measuring consumer attention and its contribution to behavior-elastic curves, the following section will delve into the application of facial coding in neuro-marketing.

3.4. Facial Coding¶

Facial coding is a valid and reliable method for analyzing consumers' emotional responses, particularly in advertising tests and product evaluation research (Kring & Sloan, 2007; Dragoi, 2021; Marketing Mind, 2024) [16]. Unlike other neuro-marketing techniques that focus on internal brain activity or visual attention, facial coding captures the outward expressions of emotions, offering a more direct and observable measure of consumer feelings. This method is particularly useful for understanding the emotional valence and intensity of consumer reactions, which can be crucial for optimizing marketing messages and product designs.

Facial coding, especially the detection of facial micro-expressions, is a key technique in neuromarketing for measuring consumer responses. Facial micro-expressions are subtle, involuntary movements that occur in response to external stimuli, typically lasting between 65 and 500 milliseconds (Yan et al., 2013) [11]. These micro-expressions are more reliable for revealing genuine emotions compared to macro-expressions, which can be voluntarily controlled and may not accurately represent emotional states. The integration of facial micro-expressions with other physiological signals, such as Electroencephalography (EEG) signals, galvanic skin responses (GSR), and Photoplethysmography (PPG) signals, enhances the reliability of emotion recognition. For instance, a model that combines facial micro-expressions with EEG, GSR, and PPG signals has been proposed to measure arousal and valence levels, providing a more comprehensive and accurate understanding of consumer emotions (Frontiers in Psychology, 2022) [11].

Specific Applications of Facial Coding¶

1. Advertising: Facial coding can be used to measure the emotional impact of advertisements. By analyzing facial micro-expressions, marketers can gain insights into how consumers genuinely react to different elements of an ad, such as visuals, music, and narrative. This can help in optimizing ad content to evoke desired emotional responses (Yan et al., 2013) [11].

2. Packaging: In packaging design, facial coding can assess consumer reactions to different designs and materials. For example, the emotional response to a product's color, texture, and shape can be measured to ensure that the packaging aligns with the brand's intended emotional message (Yan et al., 2013) [11].

3. Brand Perception: Facial coding can provide valuable data on how consumers perceive a brand. By analyzing micro-expressions in response to brand-related stimuli, such as logos, slogans, and brand experiences, marketers can understand the emotional associations consumers have with the brand and adjust their strategies accordingly (Yan et al., 2013) [11].

Complementing Other Techniques¶

Facial coding is often used in conjunction with other neuro-marketing techniques to provide a more comprehensive analysis of consumer behavior. For example, EEG measures brain activity and is commonly used in emotional studies. When combined with facial coding, EEG can offer additional insights into the cognitive and emotional processes underlying the facial responses. However, while EEG signals can provide complementary information, they do not necessarily improve the accuracy of facial expression-based emotion recognition (Soleymani et al., 2015) [11].

Eye tracking measures where a person is looking and can be used to understand which parts of an advertisement or product packaging are most engaging. When combined with facial coding, eye tracking can provide a more complete picture of consumer attention and emotional response (Koelstra and Patras, 2013) [11].

Physiological signals such as GSR and PPG measure changes in skin resistance and blood flow, respectively, which are indicators of emotional arousal. These signals can complement facial coding by providing data on the intensity of emotional responses, which are difficult to fake (Kreibig, 2010) [11].

Recent Studies¶

Recent studies have utilized facial coding to evaluate the effects of organic food labels on consumer preference, demonstrating its applicability in various marketing contexts. These findings highlight the importance of integrating multiple neuromarketing techniques to gain a comprehensive understanding of consumer behavior, particularly in the retail sector where authentic and emotionally resonant content is emphasized over traditional advertising elements (Marketing Mind, 2024) [16].

Limitations and Future Directions¶

While facial coding is a powerful tool, it faces several challenges. Detecting facial micro-expressions remains a significant challenge, particularly in handling facial macro movements, developing robust spotting strategies, and ignoring irrelevant facial information (Oh et al., 2018) [11]. The timing of genuine emotional responses can vary based on stimuli flow, participant personality, and previous experiences, requiring more research to identify the optimal time for capturing these responses (Doma and Pirouz, 2020) [11].

Future research should focus on improving the accuracy and reliability of facial coding techniques, especially in combination with other physiological measures. Additionally, ethical considerations must be addressed to ensure the responsible use of facial coding data in marketing strategies (Marketing Mind, 2024) [16].

Having examined the use of facial coding in analyzing consumers' emotional responses and its relevance in neuro-marketing, the following section will explore the methodologies for constructing behavior-elastic curves.

4. Behavior-Elastic Curves¶

Behavior-elastic curves represent a significant advancement in marketing science by integrating psychological and behavioral factors derived from neuro-marketing data into traditional economic models. Unlike price-elastic demand curves, which focus primarily on the quantitative response to price changes, behavior-elastic curves incorporate a broader spectrum of consumer behavior, including cognitive and emotional responses, to provide a more comprehensive understanding of consumer preferences and decision-making processes. This section will first define the theoretical foundations of behavior-elastic curves and then delve into the methodologies for collecting the necessary neuro-marketing data, followed by the techniques used for curve derivation and the ethical considerations associated with these approaches.

4.1. Definition and Theory¶

Behavior-elastic curves represent a significant evolution in the field of marketing science by integrating psychological and behavioral factors derived from neuro-marketing data into traditional economic models. Unlike price-elastic demand curves, which focus primarily on the quantitative response to price changes, behavior-elastic curves incorporate a broader spectrum of consumer behavior, including cognitive and emotional responses, to provide a more comprehensive understanding of consumer preferences and decision-making processes.

The theoretical underpinnings of behavior-elastic curves are rooted in the recognition that consumer behavior is influenced by a multitude of factors beyond price. These factors include consumer preferences, income levels, and psychological influences, which traditional price-elastic models often fail to capture adequately [8]. For instance, the income effect and substitution effect are key concepts that explain how changes in consumer income and relative prices influence purchasing behavior, but these effects are not always linear or predictable. Moreover, market structures, such as perfect competition, monopolistic competition, oligopoly, and monopoly, play a significant role in how consumer behavior impacts pricing. In perfectly competitive markets, consumer demand directly influences prices due to the large number of sellers, whereas in monopolistic markets, a single seller can set prices regardless of consumer demand, often leading to higher prices [8].

The advent of neuro-marketing techniques, particularly EEG, has enabled researchers to capture these nuanced cognitive and emotional responses. EEG measures brain activity by recording electrical signals on the scalp, offering real-time insights into consumer cognitive and emotional states. This technology has been widely used in consumer neuroscience and neuromarketing to analyze perceptual constructs and improve the internal validity of studies on consumer psychology [4]. For example, EEG has been employed to predict consumer preferences and emotional responses to various stimuli, such as product images, video ads, and packaging designs [4]. Studies by Yadava et al. and Teo et al. have developed predictive models using machine learning to identify consumer intentions and preferences, demonstrating the potential of EEG in enhancing marketing strategies [4].

The integration of EEG with other biometric measures, such as eye tracking and skin conductance, allows for a more comprehensive analysis of consumer behavior. Hybrid schemes combining EEG with eye tracking have been used to study visual attention to social media and its impact on restaurant visit intentions [3]. Similarly, the combination of EEG with skin conductance has been applied to understand consumer reactions to food packaging [3]. These multimodal approaches provide a more nuanced and reliable understanding of consumer responses, which is essential for the derivation of behavior-elastic curves.

Machine learning algorithms, particularly those designed for high-dimensional data, are effective in predicting consumers' future choices from EEG signals. These algorithms can process complex neural patterns and extract meaningful features that correlate with consumer behavior, enhancing the precision of behavior-elastic curve derivation [15]. For example, mutual information analysis has been used to quantify the importance of different product features, such as flavors and toppings, in influencing consumer preferences [5]. This method, combined with discrete choice experiments (DCE), offers a more natural and less biased way to measure consumer preferences, which can be integrated into traditional economic models to refine pricing strategies [5].

The use of event-related potentials (ERP) and time-frequency (TF) analysis in EEG data further enriches the understanding of consumer behavior. ERP measures, such as the N400 and P300 components, reflect cognitive and emotional processes during decision-making. The N400 component is particularly useful for detecting conflict and unfamiliarity, while the P300 component is effective in investigating advertising and marketing effectiveness [17]. TF analysis, especially the alpha band, modulates visual processing, attentional orienting, decision-making, and emotional regulation, making it a valuable tool for assessing consumer responses to advertisements and products [17].

Despite the advantages of neuro-marketing techniques, ethical considerations and limitations remain significant challenges. The responsible use of EEG data and the interpretation of brain activity must be conducted with transparency and adherence to ethical guidelines to protect consumer privacy and ensure the validity of the findings [15]. The complexity of interpreting brain signals and the challenges in translating these signals into meaningful consumer preferences are acknowledged in the literature [5]. Additionally, the spatial accuracy of EEG and the reverse inference problem, where brain activity is used to infer cognitive processes, pose ongoing challenges [7].

In summary, the theoretical foundations of behavior-elastic curves highlight the need to integrate a broader range of consumer behavior factors into traditional economic models. The practical applications of these curves, such as enhancing pricing strategies through the use of advanced neuro-marketing techniques, are promising but must be approached with careful consideration of ethical and methodological issues. The following section will delve into the methodologies for collecting the necessary data to construct these curves.

4.2. Data Collection¶

The process of collecting neuro-marketing data to construct behavior-elastic curves involves several key steps and methodologies. Electroencephalography (EEG) is a primary technique used in this context, offering high temporal resolution and the ability to capture real-time neural responses to marketing stimuli. The data collection process begins by creating realistic buying scenarios to understand consumers' thoughts and preferences when selecting products. Brain data is collected from specific regions known to be involved in emotional and decision-making processes related to purchase intention [20].

To ensure the reliability and validity of the collected data, researchers often use commercial-grade EEG headsets, such as the Emotiv EPOC wireless EEG headset with 14 channels, to collect brain signals from participants. These headsets are paired with other biometric tools, such as eye trackers, to correlate brain activity with specific choice options. For example, a study by Yadava et al. used a commercial Emotiv EPOC wireless EEG headset in combination with a Tobii-Studio eye tracker to collect brain signals and gaze data from participants while they selected their most and least favorite crackers based on shape, flavor, and topping [5]. This setup allowed for a detailed and discrete indicator of preferences, providing a natural and less biased way to measure consumer behavior.

The choice of stimuli is crucial in the data collection process. Participants are typically presented with a variety of stimuli, such as product images, video ads, and packaging designs, to elicit a wide range of cognitive and emotional responses. The stimuli are designed to be realistic and relevant to the consumer's daily experiences, ensuring that the collected data reflects genuine consumer behavior. For instance, in a study by Fu et al., participants were shown different fabrics and the EEG data was analyzed to identify neurophysiological correlates of price sensitivity and willingness to pay [7].

The integration of multiple neuro-marketing techniques, such as EEG, eye tracking, and facial coding, can provide a more comprehensive understanding of consumer behavior. For example, a hybrid approach involving EEG, eye tracking, and mutual information analysis was used to evaluate consumer preferences over crackers. The study varied the shape, flavor, and topping of the crackers and analyzed the spectral activity associated with preferences, revealing that flavors and toppings were more significant factors in influencing consumer preferences than shapes [5]. This multi-modal approach not only enhances the predictive accuracy of consumer preferences but also introduces ethical considerations, such as the need for informed consent and privacy protections for participants [5].

Ethical considerations and limitations are significant in the data collection process. The responsible use of EEG data and the interpretation of brain activity must be conducted with transparency and adherence to ethical guidelines to protect consumer privacy and ensure the validity of the findings [15]. The complexity of interpreting brain signals and the challenges in translating these signals into meaningful consumer preferences are acknowledged in the literature [5]. Additionally, the spatial accuracy of EEG and the reverse inference problem, where brain activity is used to infer cognitive processes, pose ongoing challenges [7].

Having examined the methods and processes for collecting neuro-marketing data to construct behavior-elastic curves, the following section will delve into the techniques used for curve derivation.

4.3. Curve Derivation¶

The derivation of behavior-elastic curves from neuro-marketing data involves a series of methodological steps that transform raw brain activity signals into meaningful insights about consumer behavior. These steps include data pre-processing, feature extraction, classification and statistical analysis, and interpretation. Each stage is critical for ensuring the accuracy and reliability of the derived curves.

Data Pre-Processing: The raw EEG data collected during the neuro-marketing experiments is often contaminated with noise, which can obscure the relevant brain activity. Therefore, pre-processing techniques are essential to clean the data and enhance its quality. Common pre-processing methods include filtering to remove high-frequency and low-frequency noise, artifact removal to eliminate non-brain activity (such as eye blinks and muscle movements), and normalization to standardize the data across participants [20]. These techniques ensure that the subsequent analysis is based on clean and consistent data, reducing the risk of erroneous conclusions.

Feature Extraction: Once the data is pre-processed, the next step is to extract features that are relevant to consumer behavior. Feature extraction methods can be categorized into time domain, frequency domain, and time–frequency domain analyses. Time domain analyses, such as Event-Related Potentials (ERPs), capture variations in the EEG signal aligned with specific events or stimuli. Frequency domain analyses break down the signal into different frequency bands (delta, theta, alpha, beta, gamma), each of which can provide insights into various cognitive and emotional states. For example, the alpha band is particularly useful for modulating visual processing, attentional orienting, decision-making, and emotional regulation [17]. Time–frequency domain analyses, such as wavelet transforms, can provide a more detailed view of how these states change over time. The choice of feature extraction methods depends on the specific research question and the type of data available [20].

Classification and Statistical Analysis: The extracted features are then used for classification and statistical analysis to predict consumer preferences and behaviors. Machine learning algorithms, particularly those designed for high-dimensional data, are highly effective in this context. Deep neural networks (DNN) have achieved the highest binary classification accuracy (85–94%), followed by random forests (RF) (80%), support vector machines (SVM) (77%), and k-nearest neighbors (KNN) (72%) [17]. These algorithms can process complex neural patterns and extract meaningful features that correlate with consumer behavior, enhancing the precision of behavior-elastic curve derivation. For instance, mutual information analysis has been used to quantify the importance of different product features, such as flavors and toppings, in influencing consumer preferences [5]. This method, combined with discrete choice experiments (DCE), offers a more natural and less biased way to measure consumer preferences, which can be integrated into traditional economic models to refine pricing strategies [5].

Interpretation: Proper interpretation of the derived features and classification results is crucial for constructing accurate behavior-elastic curves. The selection of appropriate pre-processing and feature extraction techniques is essential to ensure that the data accurately reflects consumer behavior. Hybrid schemes, such as combining EEG with eye tracking, electrodermal activity, and heart rate, can provide more comprehensive insights but also introduce ethical considerations. For example, the combination of EEG with eye tracking has been used to study visual attention to social media and its impact on restaurant visit intentions [3]. Similarly, the integration of EEG with skin conductance has been applied to understand consumer reactions to food packaging [3]. These multimodal approaches enhance the reliability and depth of the data, providing a more nuanced view of consumer behavior.

Ethical Considerations and Limitations: The responsible use of neuro-marketing data and the interpretation of brain activity must be conducted with transparency and adherence to ethical guidelines to protect consumer privacy and ensure the validity of the findings [15]. The complexity of interpreting brain signals and the challenges in translating these signals into meaningful consumer preferences are acknowledged in the literature [5]. Additionally, the spatial accuracy of EEG and the reverse inference problem, where brain activity is used to infer cognitive processes, pose ongoing challenges [7]. To address these issues, researchers must employ rigorous validation methods and ensure that the data is interpreted within the context of the specific research question.

Having outlined the steps involved in deriving behavior-elastic curves from neuro-marketing data, the following section will explore the impact of these curves on pricing strategies.

5. Impact on Pricing Strategies¶

The integration of behavior-elastic curves derived from neuro-marketing data into pricing strategies represents a significant advancement in the field of marketing science. This section evaluates the theoretical and empirical impacts of these curves on optimal pricing, highlighting their ability to address the limitations of traditional price-elastic models by incorporating a broader range of consumer behavior factors. We begin by examining the theoretical implications, which reveal the multifaceted nature of consumer decision-making and the need for a more dynamic approach to demand. Following this, we delve into empirical analyses that demonstrate the effectiveness of behavior-elastic curves in enhancing pricing strategies through the use of advanced neuroimaging and biometric technologies.

5.1. Theoretical Impact¶

The theoretical implications of using behavior-elastic curves for pricing decisions are profound and multifaceted. Traditional price-elastic demand curves, while useful for predicting consumer buying behavior based on price changes, have several limitations that behavior-elastic curves aim to address. Firstly, the relationship between product pricing and consumer buying behavior is more significant than that of product packaging, yet traditional demand curves may not fully account for the multifaceted nature of consumer decision-making [25]. High prices in a competitive market can lead to a permanent loss of customers, indicating that price elasticity alone does not capture the full spectrum of consumer reactions [25].

Secondly, the introduction of customer satisfaction as a mediating variable reveals that the impact of pricing on consumer behavior is more complex than a simple linear relationship. Full mediation by satisfaction implies that consumer satisfaction significantly influences the final buying decision, even when price is a primary factor [25]. This finding suggests that traditional price-elastic demand curves, which do not incorporate satisfaction, may overlook critical psychological and emotional factors that drive consumer behavior [25].

Moreover, the effectiveness of product pricing can vary depending on market conditions. For example, in a market with few competitors, higher prices may not necessarily deter consumers, whereas in a saturated market, lowering prices can significantly increase the volume of sales [25]. This variability in consumer response to price changes underscores the need for a more dynamic and context-specific approach to understanding demand, which traditional price-elastic curves may not adequately provide [25].

The integration of behavior-elastic curves into traditional economic models can offer a more comprehensive and accurate representation of consumer behavior. These curves incorporate a broader range of factors, such as consumer preferences, income levels, and psychological influences, which traditional models often fail to capture [8]. The income effect and substitution effect, which explain how changes in consumer income and relative prices influence purchasing behavior, are not always linear or predictable [8]. Therefore, behavior-elastic curves can provide a more nuanced understanding of these effects, leading to more informed and effective pricing strategies.

Furthermore, the advent of technology and the widespread availability of information have empowered consumers, increasing competition among sellers and often leading to price reductions [8]. Psychological factors, including brand loyalty, perceived value, and emotional responses, also impact consumer behavior and market pricing, leading to price differentiation where trusted brands can maintain higher prices [8]. Thus, behavior-elastic curves, which account for these broader behavioral aspects, can better predict and manage market pricing strategies.

However, the integration of neuro-marketing data into economic models presents significant challenges. Ethical concerns, particularly around consumer privacy and manipulation, are paramount. Stealth marketing, which leverages subtle persuasive cues derived from neuroscience, can influence consumers subconsciously, leading to potential ethical violations [2]. The collection and analysis of biometric and brain data must be carefully managed to protect consumer rights and prevent unauthorized use of personal information [2].

Additionally, the technical feasibility and cost of implementing behavior-elastic demand curves are important considerations. The high cost of neuroimaging technology and the specialized skills required to interpret the data pose significant financial and resource constraints [23]. These costs can limit the practical application of behavior-elastic curves, particularly for smaller businesses or organizations with limited budgets [23].

Despite these challenges, the potential benefits of behavior-elastic curves are substantial. By providing a more accurate and comprehensive understanding of consumer behavior, these curves can help businesses optimize their pricing strategies to better align with consumer preferences and market conditions. For instance, the combination of EEG and eye tracking can offer a more natural and less biased way to measure consumer preferences, which can be integrated into traditional economic models to refine pricing strategies [5].

In summary, the theoretical impact of behavior-elastic curves on pricing decisions is significant. These curves can address the limitations of traditional price-elastic demand curves by incorporating a broader range of consumer behavior factors, leading to more informed and effective pricing strategies. However, the ethical and technical challenges associated with their implementation must be carefully managed to ensure responsible and sustainable adoption. Having examined the theoretical implications, the following section will delve into the empirical analysis of behavior-elastic curves.

5.2. Empirical Analysis¶

Empirical studies have demonstrated the effectiveness of behavior-elastic curves in optimizing pricing strategies. For instance, a study by Yadava et al. used a commercial Emotiv EPOC wireless EEG headset with 14 channels to collect brain signals from participants, paired with a Tobii-Studio eye tracker to correlate brain activity with specific choice options [5]. Participants were presented with 57 choice sets, each containing three different crackers described by shape, flavor, and topping. They were asked to select their most and least favorite crackers, providing a discrete indicator of preferences. The EEG signals were analyzed in the five principal frequency bands: Delta (0–4 Hz), Theta (3–7 Hz), Alpha (8–12 Hz), Beta (13–30 Hz), and Gamma (30–40 Hz). Changes in these bands were observed to examine cognitive and affective processes in response to the choice options. Phase synchronization between the left and right frontal and occipital regions was noted, indicating interhemispheric communication during the choice task. Mutual information analysis was used to quantify the importance of different cracker features, revealing that flavors and toppings were more significant factors in influencing consumer preferences than shapes [5].

Another study by Fu et al. explored the impact of price deception and advertisement content modifications on consumer buying behavior using a hybrid approach that combined EEG with eye tracking and electrodermal activity [7]. The study found that the combination of these techniques provided a more comprehensive understanding of consumer responses, particularly in identifying subtle influences on consumer decisions that might not be apparent through traditional survey methods. The integration of EEG with other biometric measures allowed for a more nuanced and reliable assessment of consumer preferences and willingness to pay, enhancing the predictive accuracy of behavior-elastic curves [7].

A systematic review of 36 Scopus-indexed articles from 2007 to 2021 highlighted the USA's dominance in fMRI neuromarketing research, with key contributions from institutions like the California Institute of Technology, Otto-Von-Guericke University, and Aarhus University [1]. The most cited articles, such as "Marketing actions can modulate neural representations of experienced pleasantness" by Plassmann et al. (620 citations) and "Orbitofrontal cortex encodes willingness to pay in everyday economic transactions" by Plassmann et al. (563 citations), demonstrate the utility of fMRI in understanding neural correlates of consumer behavior, including decision-making, attention, emotion, and reward [1].

A study by Neurensics, a company specializing in neuro-marketing, found that fMRI signals during communications were the best predictors of actual sales, outperforming both pre- and post-messaging fMRI data and stated preferences [26]. This suggests that small-scale neuromarketing tests using fMRI can accurately forecast consumer behavior, making it a valuable tool for businesses seeking to optimize their marketing strategies. Another study recorded brain activity of 30 subjects while they decided whether to fund 36 crowdfunding projects on Kickstarter. The results indicated that brain activity, particularly in the Nucleus accumbens (NAcc), was a better predictor of market-level crowdfunding outcomes than subjects' ratings of project likeability or perceived likelihood of success [26]. This highlights the potential of fMRI to provide more reliable forecasts of mass consumer behavior, which can inform strategic decisions in fundraising and product development.

A comprehensive review of the prediction of consumer preference using EEG measures and machine learning in neuromarketing research found that deep neural networks (DNN) achieved the highest binary classification accuracy (85–94%), followed by random forests (RF) (80%), support vector machines (SVM) (77%), and k-nearest neighbors (KNN) (72%) [17]. Regression methods had the lowest accuracy (60%). These models can overcome reliability issues but require a larger number of trials and computational power, and are vulnerable to overfitting [17]. The integration of EEG with other physiological measures, such as eye tracking and electrodermal activity, can provide a more comprehensive understanding of consumer responses, which is essential for the derivation of behavior-elastic curves [17].

Having examined the empirical evidence supporting the effectiveness of behavior-elastic curves in optimizing pricing strategies, the following section will explore the challenges and limitations associated with their implementation.

6. Challenges and Limitations¶

The implementation of behavior-elastic demand curves, derived from neuro-marketing data, faces several significant challenges and limitations. These include ethical and data privacy concerns, financial and logistical barriers, technical and methodological issues, and regulatory and legal hurdles. Each of these challenges will be explored in detail, starting with the ethical and privacy issues related to the collection and use of biometric and brain data, followed by the cost and accessibility challenges, and then the methodological issues associated with integrating neuro-marketing techniques with traditional economic models. Finally, the section will examine the regulatory and legal barriers that further complicate the adoption of these advanced techniques.

6.1. Data Privacy Concerns¶

The use of neuro-marketing data to construct behavior-elastic demand curves raises significant ethical and privacy issues. Advances in neurotechnology enable businesses to predict and influence consumer behavior with a high degree of accuracy, but this comes with substantial privacy risks. The collection and analysis of biometric and brain data must be carefully managed to protect consumer rights and prevent unauthorized use of personal information [2].

Stealth marketing, which leverages subtle persuasive cues derived from neuroscience, can influence consumers subconsciously, leading to potential ethical violations. This form of marketing can manipulate consumer choices without their explicit awareness, raising concerns about informed consent and consumer autonomy [2]. Additionally, the integration of neuro-marketing data with traditional economic models can pose significant methodological challenges, particularly in ensuring that the enrollment processes for human subjects are transparent and voluntary [2].

Regulatory frameworks are crucial in addressing these ethical and privacy concerns. The European General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) provides a robust framework for protecting consumer data and ensuring ethical boundaries in the use of neuromarketing techniques. In contrast, the U.S. lacks a comprehensive federal data privacy law similar to GDPR, leading to a fragmented and complex legal landscape for businesses implementing behavior-elastic demand curves [23]. This regulatory disparity can create significant challenges for international companies, requiring them to navigate varying state-level regulations and standards.

Trust in the neuromarketing field and industry is closely linked to ethical conduct. If ethical issues are not adequately managed, there is a risk of eroding consumer trust, which can have long-term negative implications for the adoption and effectiveness of behavior-elastic demand curves [2]. Academics and business practitioners have called for the development of a robust regulatory framework to govern the use of neuromarketing data, ensuring that consumer privacy and human rights are protected [2]. Policy recommendations and ethical guidelines are necessary to address the challenges and ensure the sustainable adoption of these advanced techniques [2].

Having examined the ethical and privacy issues related to the collection and use of neuro-marketing data, the following section will delve into the cost and accessibility challenges associated with implementing behavior-elastic demand curves.

6.2. Cost and Accessibility¶

Implementing neuro-marketing techniques to derive behavior-elastic demand curves is associated with significant financial and logistical challenges. The high cost of neuroimaging technology, such as fMRI and EEG, and the specialized skills required to interpret the data pose substantial financial and resource constraints. For instance, the need for advanced labs and facilities, specialized expertise, and the lack of financial resources can limit the practical application of these techniques, particularly for smaller businesses or organizations with limited budgets [14].

The cost of fMRI, a highly effective but expensive neuroimaging technique, is a major barrier. fMRI requires specialized equipment and trained personnel to operate and analyze the data, making it a less accessible option for many companies. While fMRI provides detailed insights into deep brain regions, the financial investment required can be prohibitive [21].

Similarly, EEG, although less expensive than fMRI, still requires a considerable investment in equipment and data analysis capabilities. Commercial-grade EEG headsets, such as the Emotiv EPOC, are often paired with other biometric tools, such as eye trackers, to enhance the accuracy of the data. However, the cost of these combined systems and the need for skilled researchers to interpret the data can still be a significant barrier [20].

The time requirements for conducting neuromarketing experiments and analyzing the data are another critical challenge. These processes are often lengthy and can delay the implementation of optimal pricing strategies based on behavior-elastic demand curves. For example, the extended duration required for data collection and analysis can hinder the timely adoption of these techniques in fast-paced market environments [2].

Moreover, the lack of proper knowledge and understanding among practitioners and policymakers can further impede the growth of neuromarketing. There is a notable gap in the literature regarding the factors impeding the adoption of these techniques, including the lack of interdisciplinary expertise in both neuroscience and economics [2]. This gap can limit the effective integration and application of behavior-elastic demand curves in real-world scenarios.

Despite these challenges, there are efforts to make neuro-marketing more accessible. Less costly tools like facial coding and eye tracking are more widely adopted by neuromarketers due to their practicality and ease of use [24]. These techniques, while less comprehensive than fMRI and EEG, can still provide valuable insights into consumer behavior and are more feasible for smaller businesses and organizations.

In summary, the financial and logistical challenges of implementing neuro-marketing techniques to derive behavior-elastic demand curves are substantial. High costs, time requirements, and the need for specialized expertise can limit their practical application, particularly for smaller entities. However, the availability of more accessible tools like facial coding and eye tracking offers a viable alternative for gaining insights into consumer behavior. The following section will explore the methodological issues associated with these techniques.

6.3. Methodological Issues¶

The technical and methodological limitations of neuro-marketing techniques are significant and must be carefully addressed to ensure the reliable and valid derivation of behavior-elastic demand curves. One of the primary challenges is the technical feasibility of integrating neuro-marketing data with traditional economic models. Few marketing researchers have formal training in cognitive neuroscience, which limits the ability to conduct rigorous and reliable studies [14]. This lack of expertise also contributes to the slow penetration of neuromarketing into academic research, as researchers may struggle to interpret and apply the complex data generated by neuroimaging techniques [14].

Another critical issue is the spatial accuracy of EEG, a widely used neuro-marketing technique. While EEG offers high temporal resolution, its spatial resolution is relatively low, making it difficult to pinpoint the exact brain regions involved in specific cognitive and emotional processes. Techniques like Low-Resolution Electromagnetic Tomography (LORETA) and Global Field Power (GFP) can improve spatial accuracy, but they are not always sufficient to overcome this limitation [7]. The reverse inference problem, where brain activity is used to infer cognitive processes, further complicates the interpretation of EEG data. This problem arises because the same brain activity can be associated with multiple cognitive states, leading to ambiguous conclusions [7].

The integration of multiple neuro-marketing techniques, such as EEG, fMRI, and eye tracking, can enhance the depth and reliability of the data. However, this integration introduces additional methodological challenges. For example, the combination of EEG with eye tracking and galvanic skin response (GSR) requires sophisticated data pre-processing and feature extraction methods to ensure that the data is clean and consistent [17]. The use of machine learning algorithms, particularly those designed for high-dimensional data, can help in predicting consumer preferences and behaviors. Deep neural networks (DNN) have achieved the highest binary classification accuracy (85–94%), followed by random forests (RF) (80%), support vector machines (SVM) (77%), and k-nearest neighbors (KNN) (72%) [17]. However, these models can be computationally intensive and require a large number of trials to avoid overfitting, which can be time-consuming and resource-intensive [17].

The pre-processing of EEG data is another crucial step that can significantly impact the reliability of the results. Common pre-processing methods include filtering to remove high-frequency and low-frequency noise, artifact removal to eliminate non-brain activity (such as eye blinks and muscle movements), and normalization to standardize the data across participants [20]. These techniques are essential for ensuring that the subsequent analysis is based on clean and consistent data, reducing the risk of erroneous conclusions. However, the effectiveness of these pre-processing methods can vary, and there is a need for standardized protocols to improve replicability and reliability [20].

The choice of stimuli is also a methodological consideration. Participants are typically presented with a variety of stimuli, such as product images, video ads, and packaging designs, to elicit a wide range of cognitive and emotional responses. The stimuli must be realistic and relevant to the consumer's daily experiences to ensure that the collected data reflects genuine consumer behavior [5]. For instance, in a study by Fu et al., participants were shown different fabrics, and the EEG data was analyzed to identify neurophysiological correlates of price sensitivity and willingness to pay [7]. The selection of appropriate stimuli and the design of realistic buying scenarios are essential for the accurate derivation of behavior-elastic curves.

In summary, the methodological issues associated with neuro-marketing techniques, including the technical feasibility of integration, spatial accuracy of EEG, reverse inference problems, and the need for sophisticated pre-processing and feature extraction methods, pose significant challenges to the derivation of behavior-elastic demand curves. Addressing these issues requires a multidisciplinary approach and the development of standardized protocols to ensure the reliability and validity of the data. The following section will explore the regulatory and legal barriers that further complicate the implementation of these advanced techniques.

6.4. Regulatory and Legal Barriers¶

The use of AI and machine learning in neuromarketing to construct behavior-elastic demand curves raises significant regulatory and legal implications, particularly concerning consumer privacy and human rights. The ethical and privacy concerns associated with the collection and analysis of biometric and brain data are often inadequately addressed in commercial studies, leading to a strong need for regulatory and ethical guidelines to protect consumer interests [2]. Academics and business practitioners have emphasized the importance of developing a robust regulatory framework to govern the use of neuromarketing data, ensuring that consumer privacy and human rights are safeguarded [2].

In the European Union, the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) provides a comprehensive framework for protecting consumer data and ensuring ethical boundaries in the use of neuromarketing techniques. GDPR mandates strict data protection measures, including informed consent, data minimization, and the right to access and delete personal data. This regulatory framework is designed to mitigate the risks of data misuse and to build consumer trust in the neuromarketing field [23]. However, the U.S. lacks a federal data privacy law similar to GDPR, leading to a fragmented and complex legal landscape. State-level regulations vary widely, creating significant challenges for businesses that aim to implement behavior-elastic demand curves across different jurisdictions [23].

The application of rule utilitarianism theory helps in understanding the long-term impact of these technologies on consumer privacy and human rights. Empirical data from surveys and interviews with experts in the U.S. and Spain indicate that the long-term implications of using neuro-marketing data can deter the adoption of behavior-elastic demand curves due to potential ethical violations and consumer mistrust [23]. Michael Brammer, CEO of Neurosense, underscores the importance of scientific rigor and ethical considerations, suggesting that these issues must be addressed comprehensively to ensure responsible use of neuromarketing technologies [14].

Trust in the neuromarketing field and industry is crucial for the effective exploitation of its potential. If ethical issues are not adequately managed, there is a risk of eroding consumer trust, which can have long-term negative implications for the adoption and effectiveness of behavior-elastic demand curves [2]. Policy recommendations and ethical guidelines are necessary to address these challenges and ensure the sustainable adoption of these advanced techniques [2].

Having examined the regulatory and legal barriers to the use of behavior-elastic demand curves, the following section will explore the ethical considerations and long-term implications of these techniques.

7. Conclusion¶

This research has provided a comprehensive exploration of the integration of behavior-elastic curves derived from neuro-marketing data into traditional economic models and their impact on optimal pricing strategies. The key findings and contributions of this study can be summarized as follows:

1. Theoretical Foundations: Behavior-elastic curves represent a significant advancement in marketing science by incorporating psychological and behavioral factors beyond price sensitivity. These curves offer a more nuanced and accurate representation of consumer behavior, which traditional price-elastic demand curves often fail to capture. The integration of cognitive and emotional responses, as well as consumer preferences and income levels, provides a more dynamic and context-specific approach to understanding demand [8].

2. Neuro-Marketing Techniques: The study has reviewed and analyzed various neuro-marketing techniques, including Electroencephalography (EEG), functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging (fMRI), eye tracking, and facial coding. Each technique offers unique insights into consumer behavior, with EEG providing real-time brain activity data, fMRI offering deep insights into neural correlates, eye tracking measuring visual attention, and facial coding capturing emotional responses. The combination of these techniques, particularly through the use of machine learning algorithms, enhances the predictive accuracy and reliability of behavior-elastic curves [4][13][6][16].

3. Data Collection and Curve Derivation: The methodologies for collecting neuro-marketing data and deriving behavior-elastic curves have been thoroughly examined. Realistic buying scenarios, the use of commercial-grade EEG headsets, and the integration of multiple biometric measures are essential for obtaining reliable and valid data. Pre-processing techniques, feature extraction methods, and advanced classification algorithms, such as deep neural networks, are critical for transforming raw brain activity signals into meaningful insights about consumer behavior [5][17][20].

4. Theoretical and Empirical Impact: The theoretical implications of behavior-elastic curves suggest that they can address the limitations of traditional price-elastic models by incorporating a broader range of consumer behavior factors. Empirical studies have demonstrated the effectiveness of these curves in optimizing pricing strategies, particularly through the use of advanced neuroimaging and biometric technologies. For instance, the combination of EEG and eye tracking has been shown to provide a more natural and less biased way to measure consumer preferences, leading to more informed and effective pricing decisions [5][7][26].

5. Challenges and Limitations: The implementation of behavior-elastic demand curves faces several significant challenges and limitations. Ethical and data privacy concerns, particularly around the collection and use of biometric and brain data, are paramount. The high cost and accessibility of neuroimaging technology, technical and methodological issues, and regulatory and legal barriers further complicate their adoption. Addressing these challenges requires a multidisciplinary approach, robust ethical guidelines, and standardized protocols to ensure the responsible and sustainable use of these advanced techniques [2][23][14].

6. Future Research Directions: Future research should focus on improving the accuracy and reliability of behavior-elastic curves, particularly in the context of ethical considerations and practical applications. Developing standardized protocols for data collection and analysis, enhancing the spatial accuracy of EEG, and addressing the reverse inference problem are crucial areas for further investigation. Additionally, the exploration of regulatory frameworks and the development of ethical guidelines to protect consumer privacy and human rights are essential for the sustainable adoption of behavior-elastic demand curves in the marketing landscape [2][14].

In conclusion, the integration of behavior-elastic curves derived from neuro-marketing data into traditional economic models represents a significant step forward in the field of marketing science. These curves offer a more comprehensive and accurate understanding of consumer behavior, which can lead to more informed and effective pricing strategies. However, the ethical, financial, methodological, and regulatory challenges associated with their implementation must be carefully managed to ensure responsible and sustainable adoption. Future research should continue to explore these challenges and refine the methodologies to fully realize the potential of behavior-elastic demand curves.

References¶

1. Revolutionizing consumer insights: the impact of fMRI in neuromarketing research - Future Business Journal. Available at: https://fbj.springeropen.com/articles/10.1186/s43093-024-00371-z (Accessed: August 30, 2025)
2. Full article: Neuromarketing algorithms’ consumer privacy and ethical considerations: challenges and opportunities. Available at: https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/23311975.2024.2333063 (Accessed: August 30, 2025)
3. Electroencephalography in consumer behaviour and marketing: a science mapping approach. Available at: https://www.nature.com/articles/s41599-023-01991-6 (Accessed: August 30, 2025)
4. A systematic review on EEG-based neuromarketing: recent trends and analyzing techniques - Brain Informatics. Available at: https://braininformatics.springeropen.com/articles/10.1186/s40708-024-00229-8 (Accessed: August 30, 2025)
5. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0957417412013371. Available at: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0957417412013371 (Accessed: August 30, 2025)
6. Neuromarketing: Definition, Techniques, Examples, Pros & Cons, and Tools. Available at: https://www.neuronsinc.com/neuromarketing (Accessed: August 30, 2025)
7. Is EEG Suitable for Marketing Research? A Systematic Review. Available at: https://www.frontiersin.org/journals/neuroscience/articles/10.3389/fnins.2020.594566/full (Accessed: August 30, 2025)
8. The Impact of Consumer Behavior on Market Pricing: A Microeconomic Perspective. Available at: https://www.abacademies.org/articles/the-impact-of-consumer-behavior-on-market-pricing-a-microeconomic-perspective-17103.html (Accessed: August 30, 2025)
9. Price elasticity of demand. Available at: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Price_elasticity_of_demand (Accessed: August 30, 2025)
10. Price Elasticity of Demand: Meaning, Types, and Factors That Impact It. Available at: https://www.investopedia.com/terms/p/priceelasticity.asp (Accessed: August 30, 2025)
11. Using Facial Micro-Expressions in Combination With EEG and Physiological Signals for Emotion Recognition. Available at: https://www.frontiersin.org/journals/psychology/articles/10.3389/fpsyg.2022.864047/full (Accessed: August 30, 2025)
12. The Science (and Art) of Estimating Price Elasticities. Available at: https://arminkakas.medium.com/the-science-and-art-of-estimating-price-elasticities-f182bb56e6c4 (Accessed: August 30, 2025)
13. Neuromarketing: The popularity of the brain-imaging and physiological tools. Available at: https://neuroscirn.org/ojs/index.php/nrnotes/article/view/80 (Accessed: August 30, 2025)
14. Neuromarketing: The New Science of Consumer Behavior | Society. Available at: https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s12115-010-9408-1 (Accessed: August 30, 2025)
15. A systematic review on EEG-based neuromarketing: recent trends and analyzing techniques. Available at: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/38837089/ (Accessed: August 30, 2025)
16. Facial Coding as a Neuromarketing Technique: An Overview. Available at: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/378921043_Facial_Coding_as_a_Neuromarketing_Technique_An_Overview (Accessed: August 30, 2025)
17. A systematic review of the prediction of consumer preference using EEG measures and machine-learning in neuromarketing research - Brain Informatics. Available at: https://braininformatics.springeropen.com/articles/10.1186/s40708-022-00175-3 (Accessed: August 30, 2025)
18. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0304393219301138. Available at: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0304393219301138 (Accessed: August 30, 2025)
19. Neuromarketing — Predicting Consumer Behavior to Drive Purchasing Decisions - Professional & Executive Development. Available at: https://professional.dce.harvard.edu/blog/marketing/neuromarketing-predicting-consumer-behavior-to-drive-purchasing-decisions/ (Accessed: August 30, 2025)
20. A systematic review on EEG-based neuromarketing: recent trends and analyzing techniques. Available at: https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11153447/ (Accessed: August 30, 2025)
21. fMRI in neuromarketing. Available at: https://www.neurensics.com/en/fmri-in-neuromarketing (Accessed: August 30, 2025)
22. 13.5 Interpretation of Regression Coefficients: Elasticity and Logarithmic Transformation - Introductory Business Statistics 2e. Available at: https://openstax.org/books/introductory-business-statistics-2e/pages/13-5-interpretation-of-regression-coefficients-elasticity-and-logarithmic-transformation (Accessed: August 30, 2025)
23. (PDF) Neuromarketing Algorithms' Consumer Privacy and Ethical Considerations: Challenges and Opportunities. Available at: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/376409902_Neuromarketing_Algorithms'_Consumer_Privacy_and_Ethical_Considerations_Challenges_and_Opportunities (Accessed: August 30, 2025)
24. Review of eye-tracking: A neuromarketing technique – Neuroscience Research Notes. Available at: https://neuroscirn.org/v3i4a61/ (Accessed: August 30, 2025)
25. Impact of Pricing and Product Information on Consumer Buying Behavior With Customer Satisfaction in a Mediating Role. Available at: https://www.frontiersin.org/journals/psychology/articles/10.3389/fpsyg.2021.720151/full (Accessed: August 30, 2025)
26. https://cxl.com/blog/neuromarketing-research/. Available at: https://cxl.com/blog/neuromarketing-research/ (Accessed: August 30, 2025)